top of page

PBMs: The Most Powerful Forces in American Healthcare You’ve Never Heard Of

Writer: Theresa Barta
Theresa Barta
Oct 29
2 min read

Most Americans have never heard of PBMs. But PBMs control medications in America. They decide what medications you can get, how much they will cost you, and so much more. In other words, they control nearly every prescription written and filled in America. And they do it behind the scenes. They also influence the prices more than anyone else in the healthcare system. 


What PBMs Actually Are 


PBM stands for Pharmacy Benefit Manager. PBMs are third-party companies that get hired by insurers, employers, and government programs. Their jobs are to manage prescription drug benefits. 


Essentially, this makes them the middleman between the drug manufacturer, the pharmacy, and the insurance plan. Their job is to process claims and build out formularies (the list of drugs your insurance covers). They negotiate prices and decide which medications patients can access. 


There are three main PBMs (CVS Caremark, Express Scripts, and OptumRx) that control more than 75–80% of all prescription drug claims in the United States. And that level of control affects everyone. 


What PBMs Do 


PBMs have four main functions. 


  1. They decide which drugs your insurance will cover. 


They build the formularies, and it’s the formularies that determine which drugs are covered and “preferred”. They decide which drugs require prior authorization. And which are going to cost you more. A formulary determines whether a patient gets the medication their doctor prescribes or whether it will be replaced with a cheaper alternative. 


  1. They negotiate prices with drug manufacturers. 


In exchange for placing certain drugs on formularies, PBMs receive and negotiate huge rebates. This is a major source of revenue for them. 


  1. They decide how much pharmacies get paid. 


PBMs set reimbursement rates for pharmacies. They have the power to pay pharmacies less than the cost of the drug. This is called spread pricing, and it allows the PBMs to keep the difference. Independent pharmacies are struggling because of this.


  1. They manage prior authorization and step therapy. 


PBMs decide when patients must “fail first” using a cheaper medication before getting the one their doctor prescribed. They also decide when a doctor must get approval before prescribing certain drugs. 


Who Pays PBMs? 


PBMs are paid by multiple parties, which is why the system is so complex and profit-driven.  Insurers and employers pay PBMs administrative fees to manage prescription benefits. Drug Manufacturers pay PBMs rebates to secure favorable placement on formularies. PBMs also profit from spread pricing. Patients indirectly pay PBMs through copays, coinsurance, and being forced to use PBM preferred drugs. 


PBMs are out there deciding who gets access to what medication and at what cost. They influence every aspect of healthcare in America. And their priorities will always be profit.


 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


© 2025 Barta Law.  All Rights Reserved.

bottom of page