top of page

Denied Care is Denied Humanity: Stories of Insurance Overreach

Writer: Theresa Barta
Theresa Barta
5 days ago
2 min read

In America, health insurers deny tens of millions of claims each year. Many look at the number, at the statistics, and are shocked by them. But behind each and every single story of denied care is a human being. One who needed care. They went to the doctor, got a recommendation, and then the insurance company said no. Not happening. And sometimes the consequences are devastating.  


When insurers override medical judgment: patients pay the price.


Nataline Sarkisyan was a 17‑year‑old whose doctors said she needed a liver transplant to survive. Her health insurer denied it. They said it was “experimental”, regardless of it being the standard of care for her condition. It was only due to public outrage that their decision was later reversed and she was approved for the transplant. But the approval came too late. She passed away waiting for it. 


Profits over patience and the loss of humanity in healthcare.


Christopher McNaughton was a college student who had severe ulcerative colitis. A treatment plan developed at the Mayo Clinic finally controlled his condition. After all of the struggling he went through to get to that point, his insurer flagged him as a “high‑dollar account”. Meaning he would cost them too much money, and they started looking for ways to stop paying for his care. Employees were later found to have been laughing over the denials, calculating their cost-saving tactics by forcing him to fail first on other treatments already tested. 


When an algorithm has more say than a physician.


Little John Cupp was 61‑years‑old when his cardiologist ordered a heart catheterization for heart failure. It was rejected twice by his insurance. A cheaper stress test was approved, but he died of cardiac arrest about 36 hours after that test. It was later discovered that the insurer had used an adjustable algorithm nicknamed “the dial” to increase denial rates.


Denials in numbers.


A CBS News analysis of 1.3 billion claims found that insurers denied 19% of in‑network claims in 2024. That makes it nearly one in five. For the largest insurer, UnitedHealthcare, denial rates were even higher. These stories are far from rare. 


No one is protected. 


Dr. Dan Hurley was an ENT surgeon. He had spent his career helping patients fight denials. When he developed an ultra‑rare bone tumor, his own insurer denied PET scans, CT scans, chemotherapy, radiation, and medications. All were labeled as “not medically indicated.”


Prior authorization: the silent killer.


Across the country, patients report delays of weeks or months due to prior authorization. One archive documents a cancer patient whose chemotherapy was denied three times, delaying treatment by six weeks. That was long enough for the cancer to spread.


Insurance companies deny care because denials are profitable for them. But the hard truth is that insurers are not just denying claims. They are denying humanity.



 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


© 2025 Barta Law.  All Rights Reserved.

bottom of page